Human Rights and Taxation: Between Rights and Duties
Keywords:
Human rights, taxpayers’ rights, taxing power, human dignityAbstract
This paper examines the relationship between human rights and taxation from the perspective of taxpayers’ rights, through a narrative review of legal literature. Its central thesis is that State taxing power, although legitimate and necessary to finance public goods, is subject to substantive and procedural limits derived from human dignity and fundamental rights. The study analyzes tensions between taxing power and rights to property, liberty, privacy, and procedural guarantees, emphasizing problems arising during tax audits, assessment procedures, and tax litigation. Human dignity is presented as an axial criterion and doctrinal foundation for evaluating the legitimacy and proportionality of fiscal interventions. The paper also identifies a structural imbalance between the powers of tax administrations and the limited safeguards available to taxpayers. It proposes understanding taxpayers as persons subject to tax duties and holders of human rights, within a cooperative relationship with tax administrations based on legality, transparency, participation, and effective judicial protection.
References
Andres-Aucejo, E., Akamba, M. ., Nicoli, M. ., & Owens, J. . (2022a). General Agreement on International Tax Cooperation, Trade and Global Tax Governance: A Proposal (Part I). Review of International and European Economic Law, 1(1), 5–22. Retrieved from https://www.rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/3
Andres-Aucejo, E., Akamba, M., Nicoli, M., & Owens, J. (2022b). General Agreement on International Tax Cooperation, Trade and Global Tax Governance: A Proposal: (Part I & II). Review of International and European Economic Law, 1(2), 7–38. Retrieved from https://www.rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/28
Andrés-Aucejo, E., & Masbernat, P. (2023a). Constituciones y sistemas tributarios comparados. Revista De Educación Y Derecho, (27). https://doi.org/10.1344/REYD2023.27.42496
Andres-Aucejo, E., Akamba, M. ., Nicoli, M. ., & Owens, J. (2023b). Toward a “Global Tax Legal Order” based on international tax cooperation, human rights and global tax governance for global sustainability, under United Nations centripetal force. UN Tax policy proposals (GLOVTAXORDER¬- UNTAXPOLICY). Review of International and European Economic Law, 2(3). Retrieved from https://www.rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/36
Andrés-Aucejo, E. et alter (2023c). - Eva ANDRÉS-AUCEJO (main author), OWENS, J. (Director), et alter. The universal institutionalization of International Tax Cooperation under United Nations orbit in the new architectural design of a Global Tax Legal Order inspired by International Tax Cooperation, human rights and global tax governance. Published by UNITED NATIONS.org Andrés-Aucejo, Eva and Owens, Jeffrey_Input Tax Report.pdf (un.org)
Andrés-Aucejo, E. (2024a). “Educación fiscal” y “Tax compliance”; mejorados por Inteligencia Artificial como mecanismos de naturaleza holística integrantes de la Convención tributaria de Naciones Unidas: sobre cooperación tributaria internacional eficaz e inclusiva y de sus protocolos de desarrollo. Revista De Educación Y Derecho, (30). https://doi.org/10.1344/REYD2024.30.47753.
Andres-Aucejo, E. (2024b). The new UN TAX CONVENTION ON INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION IN TAX MATTERS as an essential pillar of a new GLOBAL TAX ORDER designed through a NEW INTERNATIONAL TAX ORGANIZATION. Review of International and European Economic Law, 3(5). Retrieved from https://www.rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/89
Andres-Aucejo, E. (2024c). The United Nations last trends on International Tax Cooperation: a new UN Tax Convention and a new International Tax Organization. Review of International and European Economic Law, 3(5). Retrieved from https://rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/92
Andrés-Aucejo, E., Remiro Brotons, A., Nicoli, M. (2024d). Holistic International Tax Cooperation. Tax education and Tax Compliance. Ethics. Artificial intelligence. Technology. ADR.
The 4th International Conference on Financing for Development: Towards a new Global Tax Order based on International tax Cooperation and Global Tax Governance - The new UN Tax Convention. www.rieel.com, Vol. 3 No. 6 (2024). Editorial. Retrieved from https://www.rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/97
Andrés-Aucejo, E., (2024e) Towards a Holistic UN Tax Convention (And Protocols), including Human, Economic, Social, Environmental and Cultural Rights: The “Substantive Issues” with Special Mention to Tax Education and Tax Compliance enhanced with Artificial Intelligence, www.rieel.com, Vol. 3, N. 6 (2024). Retrieved from https://www.rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/110
Attard, R. & Pinto de Albuquerque, P. (2023), Taxation at the European Court of Human Rights, Kluwer Law International, Nederland.
Billardi, C. (2018), Los Derechos del Hombre y su tutela jurídica en el Derecho Tributario y Financiero. Ad Hoc, Buenos Aires.
Baker, P. (2001). Should Article 6 ECHR (civil) apply to tax proceedings? Intertax, 29(6/7).
Book, L. (2018). Giving Taxpayer Rights a Seat at the Table. Temp. L. Rev., 91, 759.
Christians, A. (2016). Taxpayer Rights in the United States (October 14, 2016). "Derecho Tributario y Derechos Humanos/tax Law and Human Rights", in Derecho Tributario Y Derechos Humanos/tax Law And Human Rights, César Alejandro Ruiz Jiménez, ed. Disponible en SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2809750
Dabner, J. (2016). "Resolving Australian Tax Controversies: Does the Tax Jurisprudence under the European Convention on Human Rights Suggest a Better Way." Australian Tax Forum 31(2): 213-256.
Deak, D. (2000). Right to Right Tax Laws. Intertax, 28(3).
Deak, D. (2011). Pioneering decision of the Constitutional Court of Hungary to invoke the protection of human dignity in tax matters. Intertax, 39(11).
De Schutter, O., Lusiani, N. J., & Chaparro, S. (2021). Re-righting the international tax rules: operationalising human rights in the struggle to tax multinational companies. Human Rights and Economic Policy Reform, 124-152.
Duran Muñoz, G. D. J. (2017). Los Derechos Humanos de los contribuyentes en el Sistema Jurídico Mexicano. Letras jurídicas: Revista de los Investigadores del Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas UV, (36), 57-75.
Endresen, C. (2017). Taxation and the European convention for the protection of human rights: Substantive issues. Intertax, 45, 508.
Grau Ruiz, M. A. (2011). Decisions of the ECHR affecting domestic laws in the financial and tax field. LESIJ-Lex ET Scientia International Journal, 18(1), 9-17.
Greggi, M. (2017). Human Rights and Taxation in Italy. Itax Papers on Taxation.
Ilic-Popov, G. (2020). Dignity as a Taxpayer Right. Iustinianus Primus L. Rev., 11, 1.
Kleemans, N. (2000). Congress Review: The relationship between the national systems of legal protection of the taxpayer and the European Convention on Human Rights. EC Tax Review, 9(1).
Kofler, G., Maduro, M. P., & Pistone, P. (Eds.). (2011). Human rights and taxation in Europe and the world. IBFD, Amsterdam.
Kokott, J., and Pistone, P. (2022) Taxpayers in international law: international minimum standards for the protection of taxpayers' rights. Bloomsbury Publishing, UK.
Masbernat, P. (2002). Garantías constitucionales del contribuyente: crítica al enfoque de la doctrina nacional. Ius et Praxis, 8(2), 299-357. https://dx.doi.org/10.4067/S0718-00122002000200010
Masbernat, P., & Ramos-Fuentes, G. (2019). Asuntos tributarios en la jurisprudencia de la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos. Díkaion, 28(2), 404–439. https://0713o1djb-y-https-doi-org.itmsp.museknowledge.com/10.5294/dika.2019.28.2.8
Masbernat, P. (2024), Human Rights in Tax Litigation Before Chilean Courts (Los derechos humanos en litigios tributarios ante los tribunales chilenos) (January 02, 2024). Disponible en SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4866947 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4866947
Mirkay, N. A. (2026). Infusing Tax Policymaking with Economic Dignity. University of Hawai’i Richardson School of Law Research Paper.
Morón Pérez, M. (2026). La limitación de efectos de las sentencias que declaran la inconstitucionalidad de normas tributarias en el ordenamiento español a la luz del derecho comparado, europeo y el convenio europeo de derechos humanos, Crónica Tributaria. Nº198/2026: 121-160.
Neto, L. G., & Bonomi, L. S. (2023). The Human Dignity as a Connection between Human Rights and Tax Law. Global Journal of Human-Social Science, 1-10.
Owens, J., Andrés-Aucejo, E., Nicoli, M., Sen, J., Olesti-Rayo, R., Lopez-Rodriguez, J., & Pinto-Nogueira, J. (Dirs..). (2021). Global tax governance: Taxation on digital economy, transfer pricing, and litigation in tax matters (MAPs + ADR) policies for global sustainability. Thomson Reuters.
Owens, J. (Dirs.), Andrés-Aucejo, E. (Main author), Wolfgang, K., et al. (2023a, February). The universal institutionalization of international tax cooperation under the United Nations orbit: Towards a global tax legal order inspired by international tax cooperation, human rights, and global tax governance. United Nations Tax Report. https://financing.desa.un.org/sites/default/files/2023-03/Andrés-Aucejo,%20Eva%20and%20Owens,%20Jeffrey_Input%20Tax%20Report.pdf
Owens, J., Andrés-Aucejo, E. ., & Remiro Brotons, A. (2023b). A new Global Tax Legal Order . Review of International and European Economic Law, 2(3). Retrieved from https://www.rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/57
Owens, J., Andrés, E., Remiro Brotons, A., Nicoli, M., Fernández Pons, X., & Byrnes, W. (2024). Reference Terms Project of the UNITED NATIONS Tax Convention on International Cooperation in Tax Matters. Review of International and European Economic Law, 3(5), 5.1–5.20. Retrieved from https://rieel.com/index.php/rieel/article/view/84
Nychyporenko, О.В. (2017). Theoretical and legal principles of ensuring rights and legitimate interests of taxpayers. Scientific Works of the IAPM, (Наукові праці, МАУП), Issue 52(1), pp. 124–132, UDC 346.9
Perrou, Katerina (2022), Observatory on the Protection of Taxpayers' Rights, IBFD, Amsterdam.
Polenchuk, M. (2022). Taxpayer protection standard in international tax disputes. Law Enforcement Review. https://doi.org/10.52468/2542-1514.2022.6(2).106-119.
Quintas Seara, A. (2014). The Protection of Taxpayers’ Property Rights in Light of the Recent ECtHR Jurisprudence: Anything New on the Horizon, or Just More of the Same? Intertax, 42(4).
Saxena, S., & Pal, R. (2022). Taxpayers Rights as Human Rights-A Critical Analysis. Part 1 Indian J. Integrated Rsch. L., 2, 1.
Sawyer, A. (2000). A Comparison of New Zealand Taxpayers' Rights with Selected Civil Law and Common Law Countries - Have New Zealand Taxpayers Been 'Short-Changed'? Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, 32, 1345.
Üyümez, M. E., & Bişgin, A. (2016). A comparative analysis of taxpayer rights in Turkey and the USA. Mecmua Uluslararası Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 2, 66-75.
Vasylieva, I. (2021). Balancing the interests of taxpayers and tax authorities as the method of minimizing tax disputes. Baltic Journal of Economic Studies, 7(5), 41-48.
Vasylieva, I. (2022). Guarantee of protection of rights and interests of taxpayers in tax disputes. Baltic Journal of Economic Studies, 8(2), 36-43.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Patricio Masbernat, Gloria Ramos-Fuentes

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Professor of Law, Universidad Autónoma de Chile, Santiago, Chile. Lawyer, LLM by Universidad de Chile, PhD in Law by the Universidad Complutense de Madrid. Reporter for the IBFD's Observatory on the Protection of Taxpayers’ Rights, on Inter-American Court of Human Rights, IBFD, Amsterdam, Netherlands, IBFD, Amsterdam, Netherlands. Orcid:
Professor of Law, Universidad Autónoma de Chile, Santiago, Chile. Lawyer, LLM by Universidad Complutense de Madrid, PhD in Law by the Universidad Autónoma de Chile. Reporter for the IBFD's Observatory on the Protection of Taxpayers’ Rights, on Inter-American Court of Human Rights, IBFD, Amsterdam, Netherlands, IBFD, Amsterdam, Netherlands. Orcid: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8697-2649. Her main research line is focused on International Public Law. She is the author of dozens of scientific articles published in international journals and book chapters published by international publishers. E-mail: gloria.ramos1@cloud.uautonoma.cl